Scottish growing tool

Myths About Growing Chives in Scotland

Common claims about growing chives, checked against the evidence and written for Scottish gardens. Every verdict links to the research or authority behind it.

5 common claims about chives, checked: 3 busted0 disputed0 untested2 hold up

🌱✗ Tested and false

“Chives are an allium, so rotate them with your onions and garlic”

Chives are a perennial and do not follow annual rotation rules. They stay in the same spot for years, with no rotation recommendation needed. The rotation advice applies to annual alliums like onions and garlic.

What to do: Plant chives in a permanent spot and leave them there. Lift and divide the clump every three or four years to keep it healthy, replanting a division in the same place.

1 source
  • RHSPerennial herb; lift and divide clumps every few years; no rotation requirement stated
🌱✗ Tested and false

“Pick the flowers off chives: they are inedible and drain the plant”

Chive flowers are fully edible with a milder onion flavour than the leaves, and are used in salads and as a garnish. Removing them does encourage more leaf growth, but the flowers are a crop in their own right.

What to do: Pick chive flowers for the kitchen while they are fresh and the colour is deep purple. Leave a few for the bees, who work them heavily in late spring.

In Scotland: Chive flowers appear in May and June, when a Scottish garden has few other edible flowers. They are worth harvesting for that alone.

1 source
  • RHSPurple flowers are edible and attractive to bees
🌱✗ Tested and false

“You should lift and divide chives every year to keep them productive”

Chives benefit from division every three to four years, not annually. Dividing congested clumps in spring is the advice. Annual division disturbs a plant that is still performing perfectly well.

What to do: Divide chives in spring every three or four years, or when the centre of the clump stops producing. Cut the leaves back by half before lifting, and replant the outer sections as new plants.

In Scotland: Chives are one of the first herbs to appear in a Scottish spring, and heavy division in cold, wet soil sets them back at exactly the moment they should be powering ahead.

1 source
  • RHSLift and divide congested clumps every few years in spring
🌱✓ Evidence supports it

“Cut chives right to the ground and they grow back stronger”

Cutting chive leaves down to 2.5cm above soil level several times during the growing season is advised, to encourage fresh growth. The plant responds with a new flush of tender leaves.

What to do: Cut to about 2-3cm, not literally scalped to the soil. Do it two or three times through the growing season. After flowering, cut the whole clump back to rejuvenate it.

1 source
  • RHSCut down to 2.5cm several times during the season to encourage fresh growth
🌱✓ Evidence supports it

“Chives self-seed everywhere, and once you have them you'll never get rid of them”

Chives do self-seed freely and can become invasive if left to their own devices. The fix is simple and effective: remove the flower heads before they set seed.

What to do: Deadhead chives after flowering, before the seed heads dry and scatter. Lift and divide clumps every few years in spring to keep them vigorous, giving away or discarding the divisions you do not need.

1 source
  • RHSDeadhead after flowering to prevent self-seeding; can become invasive
Tested and false Sources disagree Never tested Evidence supports it

Plus 10 general gardening claims that apply to chives along with everything else, from sand in clay to coffee grounds and beer traps: common garden myths, checked →

What the verdicts mean

Tested and false means somebody ran the experiment and the practice did not work.Sources disagree means reputable authorities contradict each other.Never tested means the claim circulates but we found no study either way, so our own reasoning is labelled as ours.Evidence supports it is the plain case, though it often carries a condition worth reading.

Try another crop

Link copied

Copy this link